The Presbyterian Outlook

News and Articles from the The Presbyterian Outlook

Register Login Donate Subscribe

Top Search/Contact Area

  • Be A Fan

  • Follow Us

  • Photos

  • Pin It!

    • Home
      • About us
      • Advertise with Us
      • Submissions
    • Presbyterian Hub
      • Editorials
      • Outlook Features
      • Digital Issues
      • Editor’s viewpoints
      • What’s right?
      • About People
      • Calendar Check
    • News +
      Current Affairs
      • Outlook Reporting
      • Presbyterian News Service
      • Religion News Service
      • News from other sources
    • Ministry + Theology
      • InSights Opinions
      • Benedictory
      • Guest commentary
    • Faith + Culture
      • Book Reviews
      • Those with ears to hear (music reviews)
      • He/She Said
      • Movie Reviews
    • Ministry Resources
      • Outlook Standard Lessons
      • Outlook Horizons Studies
      • Looking into the lectionary
      • Bulletin Inserts
      • Webinars
      • Hymns
    • Outpost Blog
    • Classifieds
      • Classified advertising

    Wading through the murky and treacherous waters of peace

    July 24, 2014 by Kelly Allen

    GUEST COMMENTARY

    I was a member of the Middle East Issues Committee of this summer’s General Assembly.  Though we had inadequate time to address every issue with the thoroughness it deserved, the decision to divest from three American companies whose equipment is being used by the Israeli military for non-peaceful purposes was thoughtful, informed and, I believe, consistent with our stated values as a denomination.

    To portray the divestment decision as a one-sided gesture is wrong.  It could more justifiably be said that we were one-sided in our investment in equipment used in the conflict by Israel.  To redirect our investment portfolio toward products and services that are not connected to military uses is our longstanding investment policy. This is the closest policy to neutrality, which is a value many advocate in their opposition to this divestment decision.

    To continue to tie the divestment decision with “Zionism Unsettled” is wrong.  I daresay most members of the Middle East Issues Committee of the General Assembly did not read “Zionism Unsettled,” but were very clear in wanting to separate the divestment decision from this paper. My sense is that this group did not feel qualified to evaluate this document.  Many critics are saying this separation cannot be made.  But these nuances must be made if any productive dialogue about peace in Israel/Palestine is to happen.  Otherwise every concern, every form of advocacy for human rights, every criticism of government policies of Israel can be dismissed as wanting Israel destroyed or the Jewish people wiped out. This effectively shuts down anything resembling true dialogue.

    Conflating criticism of the Israeli military’s policies and actions in the occupied territories with a position on the state of Israel itself is wrong. I write this on July 4, the day on which we celebrate the freedoms we enjoy in the United States.  These democratic freedoms are also enjoyed within the state of Israel, and arguably are absent in too many nations, including those influenced by rigid Islamic ideology.  But just as the United States has carried out policies antithetical to democratic freedom in territories outside its borders, so has Israel.  There are countless examples of the U.S., out of fear of communism, for example, undermining the very democratic values we are famous for upholding on our own soil. This has often happened through our military support of harsh regimes such as those in Central America and Africa in the 1980s. While there are Palestinians within Israel that enjoy many important rights, the same is not true for Palestinians in the West Bank.  Divestment supporters and divestment critics are both guilty of not making this important distinction.

    To label divestment as “hate” is wrong.  Even if this policy is misguided or ineffective, it is not hate. It is a nonviolent attempt to further peace in a complex situation, along with strategies and efforts that were celebrated throughout the assembly: schools attended by Arab and Israeli children, interfaith dialogue efforts throughout the U.S. and investment in economic development throughout the region.

    Rabbi Jacobs of the Union of Reform Judaism stood on the General Assembly floor and implored us not to make the decision to divest from these three companies, claiming that the relationship between Presbyterians and the American Jewish community was “at a crossroads.” I feel certain that representatives of the PC(USA) would not be invited to address a gathering of the Union of Reform Judaism about its investment policies. The fact that our denominational decision-making allows for the contributions of many voices should be applauded, even if the advice is not heeded in the way some would prefer.  Our relationship with the American Jewish community should not be threatened because we decide to put our economic house in order in a particular way.

    At one point not so long ago, the mention of a “two-state solution” raised as much ire as this divestment decision does today. I can only hope that, as we wade through the murky and treacherous waters of peace in the Middle East, God’s spirit will accompany, guide and judge us.

    Kelly AllenKelly S. Allen is the pastor of University Presbyterian Church in San Antonio, Texas, and was a commissioner to the 221st General Assembly where she served as a member of the Middle East Issues Committee.

    ShareShare on Facebook
    Facebook
    Tweet about this on Twitter
    Twitter
    Email to someone
    email
    Tagged With: GA221 • Israel/Palestine

    Commentary/ General Assembly (2014) Tags: Featured Home Page/ GA221/ Israel/Palestine

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Related Posts

    • General Assembly committee opens door for Presbyterian ministers to perform same-sex marriages (Updated and expanded)

      A General Assembly committee has opened the door for ministers in the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) to perform same-sex marriages – which, if the full assembly follows that direction later this week, could be a momentous step which would both thrill supporters of marriage equality and drive more of those who…

    • The missional Pilgrimage

      Know some folks who like to travel?  How about traveling as a group? How about traveling to the land of Israel-Palestine and Jordan? How about tracing the steps of Paul? How about visiting those places that still reverberate the voices of Athanasius and Patrick, Luther and Calvin, Zwingli and Knox?…

    • Looking past the cover: Selecting the best curricula for your congregation

      Step 1: Gather a large quantity of curriculum samples Don’t throw away those packets of postcards that appear in every church’s mailbox! Instead, send off for the myriad free samples offered. Ask publishers if you can receive curricula on 30- or 60-day trial, or if they have samples of past…

    Current Issue

    • April 16, 2018
    • March 26, 2018
    • March 5, 2018
    • Feb. 12, 2018
    • Subscribe
    • Give a Gift
    • Read Online
    • Most Commented
    • Most Popular
    • Merger of OGA and PMA not recommended OUTLOOK — The All Agency Review Committee and the Way Forward Commission have jointly decided not to recommend a merger...
    • All Agency Review Committee asks: What are the problems that need to be addressed? LOUISVILLE (Outlook) – With the idea of merging the Office of the General Assembly and the Presbyterian Mission Agency now...
    • Tony De La Rosa resigns as interim executive director of PMA Tony De La Rosa, interim executive director of the Presbyterian Mission Agency, has resigned, apparently effective immediately, and David D....
    • A prayer for Charlottesville Outlook editor Jill Duffield, who lives in Charlottesville, wrote this prayer after participating, along with other clergy, in a call...
    • Hymn: "If We Just Talk of Thoughts and Prayers" Thanks to Carolyn Winfrey Gillette, this hymn is free for congregations to use in worship. It was written after the...
    • Pastoring a purple church   The steaming mad email arrived Sunday afternoon. The subject line read: “Leaving White Memorial.” The writer, a member whom I...

    Keep the Faith

    Sign Up for Updates and Breaking News in your inbox

    Facebook

    Tweets by presoutlook
    Follow Us

    View Stories From

    • Presbyterian Hub
      • Editorials
      • Outlook Features
      • Digital Issues
      • Calendar Check
      • About People
        • Anniversaries
        • Ordinations
        • Retired
        • Deaths
        • Transitions
      • Archives
    • Faith + Culture
      • Book Reviews
      • Movie Reviews
      • He/She Said
    • Ministry + Theology
      • InSights Opinions
        • For Church Leaders
        • Faith Matters
        • Multichannel Church Report
        • #amen
        • Commentary
        • Benedictory
      • Liturgical Year
        • Advent
        • Lent

    The Latest:

    Internal team chosen to manage the Presbyterian Mission Agency

    April 26, 2018

    Stony Point to receive year-by-year funding from Presbyterian Mission Agency

    April 26, 2018

    Dispute over Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), A Corporation appears to be headed to the 2018 General Assembly

    April 26, 2018

  • Tweet With Us
  • Be A Facebook Fan
  • Our World in Photos
  • Pin With Us
  • CONTACT US:

    1 N. 5th St., Suite 500

    Richmond, VA 23219

    T: 800-446-6008F: 804-353-6369

    [email protected]

    Or ▶ Fill Out Our Contact Form

    © Copyright 2018 The Presbyterian Outlook. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Statement. Website Design by Poka Yoke Design

    • About us
    • Presbyterian Hub
    • Ministry Resources
    • Classifieds
    • Advertise with Us
    • Submissions
    7ads6x98y