Looking into the lectionary
12th Sunday after Pentecost (Proper 15)
20th Sunday in Ordinary Time
Matthew 15:21-28
August 16, 2026
Some moments can be incredibly jarring.
The 2006 World Cup final between Italy and France was tied at one goal apiece during overtime. French star player Zinedine Zidane had announced that this tournament would be his last. With about ten minutes left in overtime, he was shown a red card and ejected from the game.
It was a foul away from the ball, so the television audience was confused. The replay showed Zidane jogging away from Italian defender Marco Materazzi who was taunting him. Zidane turned and headbutted him in the chest, knocking him to the ground.
Italy won the game and the tournament in penalty kicks.
Jesus and the Canaanite woman
Some of Scripture can be incredibly jarring, too.
A woman approaches Jesus in dire need: her daughter is tormented by a demon. Jesus ignores her.
The disciples suggest sending her away: she’s being too loud. Jesus assures them that he “was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel” not, he implies, to this foreign mother and daughter.
But she was determined: “Lord, help me.”
Jesus responds harshly: “It is not fair,” Jesus tells the woman, “to take the children’s food and throw it to the dogs.” Jesus is giving voice to an ethos of isolationism, a strict separation between native “children” and foreign “dogs.”
Those of us who seek a loving Jesus who invites sinners and outcasts might be baffled. We might be disappointed. We might need time to process our emotions or to untangle a variety of theological puzzles. We might pick something else to preach on this Sunday.
But if we turn from the text, we also turn from the woman in need. We wouldn’t hear her wisdom as she critically interprets the world around her. Unlike Jesus echoing a perspective of powerful nativism, she interprets the world as it impacts her: a foreign woman advocating for the healing and safety of her daughter.
The Canaanite woman’s challenge to exclusion and isolationism
“Yes, Lord,” she continues, “yet even the dogs eat the crumbs that fall from their masters’ table.” We find ways to survive, she is saying, even when those at the table won’t voluntarily give us food. Or mercy. Or healing.
This second jolt should be felt by those who share an isolationist view: “the miracles of our messiah are for us. Not for you.” But now, they find out that these foreign “dogs” still get some benefit from their leader’s teachings, their messiah’s power.
She speaks the truth that the children at the table are more connected to the foreigners than they thought: the walls they had built were permeable. And this realization could have moved them in a couple directions.
On the one hand, they could feel anger or fear and more voraciously protect even the crumbs that fall from their plates so that all their food would be for them.
On the other, they could feel shame that others are forced to live off the crumbs of their feast, realize that this is truly unfair, and add seats to their table so that all who hunger may be fed.
Jesus heals the Canaanite woman’s daughter and expands the meaning of faith
Those who doubled down on exclusion, who would have hoarded their crumbs, would be rattled once again when Jesus responds to the woman in verse 28: “Woman, great is your faith! Let it be done for you as you wish.” And her daughter was healed from that moment. Their messiah healed one of “the dogs” and praised her faith.
This passage is three startling moments: Jesus’s harsh isolationism, the woman’s cultural critique, and Jesus healing her daughter. These three moments end in one important lesson.
Justice, inclusion and transformation
In this passage, the familiar lesson that Jesus transforms the lives of those around him is layered. Jesus offers a definition of fairness that only seems like justice in a society characterized by strict separation. The abrasive statement causes inclusivists to recoil and separatists to cheer, but they would all hear the Canaanite mother speak.
Hers is the prophetic voice pointing out how that world really works. She knows that she will navigate a broken system to save her daughter when that’s the only path immediately available to her. She will reach for crumbs when she deserves a seat at the table: not because it is right or just, but because she must.
And lest any of the shocked readers or any of the disciples within the text seek to fortify a world of impenetrable walls and closed tables, Jesus transforms that world – and its vision of justice – by praising the woman’s faith and healing her daughter.
We confess that we are willing to listen to Jesus and we confess that Jesus is transforming the world.
May Jesus continue to open our hearts so that we might also listen to those in need when they describe why the world ought to be transformed.
The potential of jarring moments
In 2010, Zidane and Materazzi both happened to be at the same hotel in Milan, Italy. They spoke. They shook hands. They moved forward. Materazzi told the press that “what was said stays between us.”
Those who paid attention to this year’s World Cup also know that 20 years after his red card, Zidane has been named the next coach of France’s national team.
Jarring moments are always part of a much larger story.
Questions for reflection on Matthew 15:21-28
- What was your reaction to Jesus telling the woman that it would be unfair “to take the children’s food and throw it to the dogs”?
- Can you think of any other jarring moments that are part of a larger story?
- How does your church respond when someone arrives seeking help?
View the corresponding Order of Worship for the 20th Sunday in Ordinary Time.
Sign up for worship resources in your inbox every Monday.
