Seminaries are struggling. These struggles cannot be understood school by school, nor can they be understood by thinking of theological education as a sector. The entire institutional ecology in which the modern seminary came to life is becoming unsustainable. Changes of this magnitude have happened before, and the church has found new ways to cultivate faithful study and form wise leaders. But it has required more than smarter management. It has required dying and rising with Christ.
Signs of stress run throughout theological education. Just this spring, Chicago Theological Seminary announced that it was suspending admission to all its degree programs and arranging teach-outs for current students. Memphis Theological Seminary closed its doors entirely. Other venerable schools are surviving by selling all or part of their campuses — like Luther Seminary, the flagship seminary of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA), and Colgate Rochester Crozer Divinity School, the alma mater of the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. More than 40 others are finding ways to embed with larger schools, as Andover Newton did with Yale Divinity School in 2017. The financial stresses are systemic: The Association of Theological Schools (ATS) recently found that about half of member schools regularly operate with a deficit.
We do this work trusting that theological education will continue — not because we get a new model right, but because God longs to be known.
The 10 ATS-accredited seminaries of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) have shown remarkable resilience in this climate. But they have not been immune to systemic stresses. In the fall of 1994 – my senior year of seminary – these 10 seminaries enrolled 4,200 across all degree programs. Thirty years later, in the fall of 2024, the total combined enrollment was 1,546 — a drop of more than 60%. Schools have responded with great creativity: selling property, embedding in universities, reaching out to new communities and more. But the challenges endure.
…the church has found new ways to cultivate faithful study and form wise leaders. But it has required more than smarter management. It has required dying and rising with Christ.
While the challenges are sharp, the story is complex. Overall, ATS schools last year enrolled more than 81,000 students, the highest number in 20 years, and more than half of ATS schools showed year-over-year gains in the 2025-26 school year. Perhaps the numbers are not simply a case of declining enrollment in a secularizing world. But what is happening?
Albert Mohler Jr. of Southern Baptist Seminary has crowed that evangelical schools are growing while more progressive schools are shrinking. That’s a partial reading. It is true that the largest ATS schools are evangelical, and growth in a few of them accounts for most ATS growth. Liberty University’s Rawlings School of Divinity, for example, boosted total ATS enrollment by more than 4,800 students when it was first added to nationwide data in 2018.
On the other hand, a 2025 study by Nathan J. McKanna of Dallas Theological Seminary found that, on average, enrollment at evangelical ATS schools has declined by about 25% in the past 20 years. Even distinguished schools like Fuller and Gordon-Conwell have seen enrollment declines severe enough to force talk of selling their campuses. Liberty, too, has laid off faculty in recent years. Stress is not limited to mainline theological schools. It runs throughout theological education.
A nuanced analysis of trends
A better reading of the data highlights four trends:
- Students are increasingly concentrated in a small number of very large institutions. Almost a third of the entire ATS head count is now enrolled in the 10 largest schools. If those schools are overwhelmingly evangelical, then size, not theological orientation, correlates most strongly with growth.
- Students are doing significantly more work online. Just 3% of ATS students did any distance-learning education in 2000; about 70% do some work online now. And almost half of Protestant students in ATS schools study exclusively online.
- Degrees have proliferated. At the core of this movement is the steady shift from the Master of Divinity – the historical, three-year “gold standard” professional degree – toward some kind of Master of Arts degree that requires just one or two years of study. In the fall of 2022, for the first time in ATS history, more students sought an M.A. than an M.Div. The shift is compounded by the incredible variety of academic and professional M.A. degrees. Across more than 280 member schools, ATS approves nearly 250 different M.A. degrees.
- The M.Div. itself is shrinking to meet the M.A. McKanna’s study found that more than two-thirds of the theological schools in his sample had reduced the number of hours required for the M.Div. between 2003 and 2023. Further reductions happen through competency-based credit and stacking of credits from one certificate or degree to another.
For better and worse, seminaries are reaching for models beyond professional education.
Together and separately, these trends cannot be assimilated to tell simple stories about mainline malaise, much less a general secularization that leaves people uninterested in theology. Rather, they point to a steady blurring of the professional boundaries that an M.Div. used to mark. For better and worse, seminaries are reaching for models beyond professional education. These trends reflect both the cause and the effect of a larger unraveling, as the bundle of institutions that has done so much to structure religion in America – especially for Presbyterians – comes undone.
A time between the times
The seminaries we know today arose as part of an institutional revolution in the early national period. That revolution was so successful that it is difficult to imagine a world without these institutions. But the seminary as a distinct, postbaccalaureate professional school preparing people for many kinds of ministry is relatively new.
The first European settlers did not found separate seminaries. They brought with them visions of a society in which church, state, economy, culture and family were more fully integrated in something like what Connecticut called its “Standing Order,” a set of elite families with an official church, generally united in a single political party. Within the established church, congregations served entire communities in ways that transcended membership. Ministers functioned more like public officials than portable professionals, and different ecclesial movements took their place not as equal denominations, but as established or dissenting churches. Theological education both mirrored and secured this kind of integration. It did not entail a separate course of study, nor did it require a separate institution. Rather, it infused the college’s singular curriculum. People preparing for ministry supplemented this general course of study with an apprenticeship with a more seasoned pastor.
Disestablishments of many kinds broke up such “standing orders.” Individual states both anticipated and followed the First Amendment’s disestablishment at the federal level in 1791. These laws reflected deeper disestablishments already underway, driven by a growing market economy, rising migration, religious revivals and more.
Disestablishment alarmed those most invested in the old social imaginary. When Connecticut disestablished the Congregationalist Church in 1814, minister Lyman Beecher fumed that “the church is extinct, and the house of God is in ruins.” To him it felt like the end of the world. And in a way, it was.
But in the wake of disestablishment, a new constellation of institutions arose. Congregations became voluntary associations. Ecclesial movements became denominations, taking their place among peers under a shared national canopy. Over time, ministers became something like professionals. And with the founding of Andover Theological Seminary in 1807, a new kind of school emerged: a (mostly) postbaccalaureate seminary specifically designed to train ministers. The model fit the times, and it spread rapidly to different denominations and regions. By 1840, more than 50 schools on this new model had been established, including predecessors of most of today’s Presbyterian seminaries.
The institutions of this new constellation made sense together. And now they are struggling together. Congregations are bifurcating in size. A few very large congregations serve a significant chunk of total membership, while a large number of smaller congregations have a shrinking membership. In the PC(USA), for instance, the 37 largest congregations have almost as many members as the 3,832 congregations with 50 members or fewer.
Disestablishment alarmed those most invested in the old social imaginary.
Crucially, both very large and very small congregations start to function less like voluntary societies. Very large congregations create economies of scale that let paid staff provide a wide range of services, even as they involve a smaller proportion of members in governance. And very small congregations tend to become more like extended families or house churches — or exhaust themselves trying to keep going as programmatic voluntary associations. This change does not center only in congregational numbers. It reflects a change in congregational form.
Both very large and very small congregations need fewer of the professionalized ministers that today’s seminaries are designed to produce. Very large congregations stretch pastoral staff to serve more people, often filling in the gaps with dedicated paraprofessionals who might have a certificate or even an M.A. Smaller congregations of 53 members – now the median size in the PC(USA) – often cannot afford a full-time minister of Word and Sacrament. Commissioned ruling elders (CREs) are playing increasingly important roles in leading both these smaller congregations and new worshiping communities.
Other denominations are seeing analogous developments: Almost half of ELCA congregations can’t afford a full-time pastor, and the United Methodist Church’s ranks of local pastors continue to grow. Part-time and paraprofessional church leaders often make extraordinary sacrifices to do extraordinary work. But the shift in ministry is still profound, especially for traditions that have invested the most in professionalization.
Both very large and very small congregations need fewer of the professionalized ministers that today’s seminaries are designed to produce.
These challenges are not peculiar to religious organizations. Many professions are dissolving as profit-seeking penetrates more sectors of society. Likewise, voluntary associations of every kind – political parties, labor unions, fraternal organizations, even bowling leagues – struggle to maintain membership and relevance.
At a deeper level, the social imaginary that crowned all these institutions with a halo of meaning is also losing its power to make such meaning. I see this trend in the vocations of the students I know best at the Candler School of Theology and other seminaries. They might be eager to undertake faithful study and courageous ministries of care and justice, but fewer are drawn to professional leadership of voluntary associations. The existing institutional order does not resonate for them as it did for past generations. As it did for me.
A whole industry has arisen to scold people back into voluntary associations. After 50 years, it has made little impact. I’m convinced this lack of impact is because the individualization breaking up this social imaginary is not a moral failing, one that a great sermon or a popular sociological treatise can correct. The individualization unraveling the order is – like the disestablishments that broke up “standing orders” – a complex process that involves powerful material forces, like the conversion of shared pension plans into individual retirement accounts, and the replacement of shared city newspapers with algorithmically customized feeds.
We have good reasons to resist these developments. But they are now so deeply rooted that simply restoring the old order is not an option. Moreover, we must acknowledge how the constellation that is now passing away aligned itself with sin. Congregations, as voluntary associations, adapted readily to Jim Crow segregation. Professionalization of ministry smuggled in norms of Whiteness and masculinity. Prizing institutions over individuals gave excuses to those who chose to cover up sexual abuse and misconduct.
The essential Reformed insight for a time like this – a time between the times – is that no institutional form is identical to or necessary for the redeeming work of God. The church has been shot through with both sin and glory in every age. The work of discipleship always involves the work of discernment.
Discernments, plural
I offer a longer version of this argument in my 2023 book The End of Theological Education. That book, as Barbara G. Wheeler noted in her review in the Outlook, offers more diagnosis than prescription. She was right. In the book, I did not offer a blueprint for a next version of theological education; rather, I offered a framework for discernment. The work of discernment is always local and particular. It asks not what God is doing in general, but what God is doing here, now, among our neighbors and ourselves.
Candler has taken up a fresh round of discernment with particular intensity in the last decade. We started by asking who our neighbors are now, in a rapidly changing Atlanta, giving special attention to those neighbors whom the process of professionalization had led us to exclude. These questions led us into an open-ended, asset-based community organizing process with our neighbors, including African immigrants, Asian Americans, African Americans and Hispanic/Latine people. Participants also represented diverse theological traditions, including charismatic and Pentecostal denominations, queer-affirming denominations and others. We asked our neighbors what God was doing among them. We asked about their gifts and their needs. We asked what we might do together.
That process has generated many goods, especially a new set of just and durable partnerships that bring life to every project. Candler’s partnership with the Asociación para la Educación Teológica Hispana (AETH), in particular, informs every one of a series of initiatives that reach for modes of theological education beyond professional education.
The work of discernment is always local and particular. It asks not what God is doing in general, but what God is doing here, now, among our neighbors and ourselves.
The Candler Foundry, for instance, offers public theological education designed not just for professional ministers but for people with all kinds of relationships to faith and church, including indifference and even hostility. Led by Hebrew Bible scholar Ryan Bonfiglio, the Foundry is a site for exploring existential questions and forming everyday discipleship. The Foundry creates some courses and events through partnerships with congregations. Others are not mediated by any voluntary association at all. Since its founding in 2020, the Foundry has offered more than 160 courses in the community that have enrolled more than 6,200 students.
Its online TheoEd talks have been viewed more than 400,000 times. Podcasts, social media, special events, short videos and a wide range of courses make theological education accessible to all.
The “all” that the Foundry reaches includes many people who have left the church or who never found it in the first place. Foundry programs connect with deep desires for meaning in individualized lives. They do not require affinity with a voluntary association as an implicit prerequisite, as so many church programs do. And they liberate serious biblical and theological studies from the preprofessional frame that is part of the deep structure of the modern seminary.
Candler’s La Mesa Academy for Theological Studies stretches beyond the professional model in a different way. Led by Associate Dean Joanne Solis-Walker, a scholar of leadership and an experienced founder of programs that reach underserved groups, La Mesa offers a graduate certificate in theological studies that is included in Emory University’s regional accreditation and is certified by AETH. La Mesa is especially attuned to the formation of CREs in the PC(USA) and analogous leaders in other traditions. Many La Mesa students serve new immigrant communities. Others serve older congregations that can no longer afford a full-time pastor; some serve on the staffs of large congregations. And an important group serves historically Black, queer-affirming, charismatic and Pentecostal churches in the Fellowship of Affirming Ministries.
La Mesa is designed to be radically accessible. Costs are very low. Students do not need to have completed a bachelor’s degree to begin. They can complete the certificate in Spanish or English — and soon in Korean. Every part of the curriculum attends to students’ cultural contexts. A hybrid format leverages the communities that students already serve as part of their formation; a cohort model builds a new community among them. At the graduation of the first cohort in May of this year, historian Justo González stressed the significance of the moment. “Years from now,” he said, “when someone writes about the history of theological education in the United States, they will write about how its methods, goals, curriculum, and practices have changed. And they will not be able to tell that story without mentioning … La Mesa, and without mentioning this class.”
I hear those words as both encouragement and exhortation.
La Mesa and the Candler Foundry both try to engage the lived stuff of this age – the ambivalent, individualized people we are, and the ways we do and do not come together – for the sake of deeper study that opens into faithful witness. Neither program was designed to prop up the professional model. Yet each is already strengthening Candler’s professional degrees, both in enrollment numbers and in breadth of vision. Other schools will find other ways that better reflect their own contexts and commitments. Discernments are always plural. We do this work trusting that theological education will continue — not because we get a new model right, but because God longs to be known.