United through Christ, bound to each other
Rhonda Mawhood Lee’s Horizons Bible Study
Lesson 5: 1 Corinthians, Chapters 8-10
On the face of it, it seems irrelevant. What does eating meat that has been offered to idols have to do with us?
In the ancient world, meat was expensive, and many people had a predominantly lacto-vegetarian diet. Meat sacrificed to idols revealed one’s dedication to the god. The leftover meat could be sold in the market. For some Jews and Christians, eating such meat was itself idolatry; it was better to not eat meat at all than to pollute oneself with idol-consecrated food. Paul called these people “weak” in conscience. The weak could have been those new to the faith, whose participation in pagan worship was fresh in their minds.
Other Christians in Corinth could eat the meat without guilt because it did not tempt them to change their beliefs. Paul calls these people “strong” in knowledge.
One might think Paul would simply tell the church what to believe. “Paul’s solution to this conflict is not to encourage those with a weak conscience to grow more in knowledge and agree that there is only one God,” writes Jeehi Park in “Working Preacher.”
“Instead, he asks those with the knowledge to grow in love.”
Paul told those who are strong to do nothing that causes another person to stumble and lose their faith. Those with a resilient conscience believed that it was their right to eat what they wanted, but Paul asked them to curtail their freedom for the sake of those whose conscience was not as robust as theirs. Paul teaches them that “all things are permitted, but not all things are beneficial. All things are permitted, but not all things build up.” (I Corinthians 10:23)
We sometimes act as if our personal freedom or our knowledge should take precedence over others’ needs. But sometimes we must consider everyone’s spiritual health.
In our highly charged culture, many of us view our faith through the lenses of our political party. We may think that, of course, Jesus would agree with us. Indeed, national surveys have documented that each political party sees the other party as godless. A pastor who does ministry along the Appalachian Trail was told by one hiker that he could not believe anyone could be both Christian and a Democrat. The pastor disagreed but, focusing on building up the entire group, chose not to comment and brought the discussion back to the Scripture at hand.
Some years ago, a session discussed the church’s funeral policy. One elder asked if it would be appropriate to have a flag-draped coffin when the memorial service is for a veteran “That might be alright,” said another elder.
“What if a person is Korean?” another elder asked, “Should we allow the Korean flag to be displayed on the casket?”
“I grew up in Romania under a dictatorship, and the national flag was in the sanctuary as an expression of his control” said another. “I don’t think any flag should be in the sanctuary because we only worship God, not the government.”
The session voted against flags in the sanctuary but to allow military rites at the gravesite. Here, sound theology was lived out in a way that benefited many.
Paul’s main concern, in I Corinthians 8-10, is how we live in Christian love with one another. We focus on what builds up the whole body of Christ, but this does not mean that we seek to please everyone. There are instances in which we must take a theological stand.
At the 227th General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), Christian nationalism was condemned as incompatible with the teachings of Jesus and church leaders were urged to stand against it. According to an article written by John Bolt in the Presbyterian Outlook, “PC(USA) labels White Christian nationalism ‘Theological Error.’” Christian nationalism seeks “to merge national identity with Christian identity, distorting both faith and politics. It contradicts the foundational commitments and public witness of our church: love, equality, inclusion, peace, religious freedom and the image of God of all beings.”