The Presbyterian Outlook

News and Articles from the The Presbyterian Outlook

Register Login Donate Subscribe

Top Search/Contact Area

  • Be A Fan

  • Follow Us

  • Photos

  • Pin It!

    • Home
      • About us
      • Advertise with the Outlook
      • Submissions
    • Presbyterian Hub
      • Editorials
      • Outlook Features
      • Digital Issues
      • Editor’s viewpoints
      • What’s right?
      • Let’s connect
    • News +
      Current Affairs
      • Outlook Reporting
      • Presbyterian News Service
      • Religion News Service
      • News from other sources
    • Ministry + Theology
      • InSights Opinions
      • Benedictory
      • Guest commentary
    • Faith + Culture
      • Book Reviews
      • He/She Said
      • Movie Reviews
    • Ministry Resources
      • Outlook Standard Lessons
      • Outlook Horizons Studies
      • Worship Resources
      • Looking into the lectionary
      • Bulletin Inserts
      • Webinars
      • Hymns
      • Faith Formation Resources
    • Outpost Blog
    • Classifieds
      • Classified advertising

    Presbyterian Scholars Conference: What happens when mainliners sit at table with split P’s?

    December 2, 2016 by The Presbyterian Outlook Leave a Comment

    Guest commentary by Chuck Wiggins

    “I often wonder what kind of shape the Presbyterian Church would be in today if the Orthodox Presbyterians, the PCA, the Evangelical Presbyterian Church and ECO had not departed,” mused Joseph D. Small, former Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) Theology & Worship director.

    untitledThose particularly thought provoking words came during the recent Presbyterian Scholars Conference held October 18-19 at Wheaton College in Illinois.

    A glimpse of that musing was evident as 30 scholars from various streams of the Presbyterian enterprise gathered to offer papers and exchange remarks on “the future of American Presbyterianism.”

    From my perspective, the spirit and the tenor of the conference with scholars from the PC(USA), OPC, EPC, and ECO under one roof during both the lectures and at table during meals was — how shall I say it — downright genial.

    Headlining a list of outstanding scholars besides Small, included Bradley Longfield of University of Dubuque Theological Seminary; OPC historian extraordinaire and Hillsdale College professor Darryl Hart; and George Marsden, distinguished professor from Notre Dame University and arguably the premier historian of American church history.

    img_20161019_194507Perhaps the highlight of the conference was the celebration of the 25th anniversary of the publication of Longfield’s groundbreaking work, “The Presbyterian Controversy: Fundamentalists, Modernists & Moderates.” Longfield’s award-winning book has been widely regarded by Presbyterians of all theological stripes as an even-handed analysis of the fundamentalist-modernist controversies of the 1920s and 1930s and their aftermath. (In my opinion, previous historical narratives by mainline P’s have largely tended to dismiss departing conservatives as simplistic cranks; while the “split P’s” have approached their forbears uncritically with a kind of surreal, hagiographic reverence.)

    The Presbyterian Scholars Conference serves a laudable purpose. Conference convener Jeff McDonald sees it as a bold outreach to professors, laypeople, seminary students and Ph.D. students, thus providing a scholarly discussion of Presbyterian history, theology and other related fields.

    McDonald, pastor of Avery Presbyterian Church in Bellevue, Nebraska, and adjunct professor of church history at Sioux Falls Seminary in Omaha, Nebraska, states his case up front: “Our goal in the PSC is to provide grants for ‘evangelical’ Presbyterian Ph.D. students. This is a Pan-Presbyterian initiative seeking to encourage theological renewal throughout Christ’s church and the advancement of evangelical Presbyterian scholarship. ”

    Particularly engaging to me was Small’s paper, “Where (in the world) is the One Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church?” In it, Small unearthed some choice comments by John Calvin lamenting needless divisions in the church.

    “Ranked among the chief evils of our time,” Calvin agonized in “Letter to Cranmer” is that “the Churches are so divided that human fellowship is scarcely now in any repute among us … that the members of the Church being severed [while] the body lies bleeding.”

    As Small put it: “Calvin’s distress went beyond regret, for it led him to greet with enthusiasm Cranmer’s proposal for a general council of all the reformation churches in order to bring unity out of separation. A few years later his vision broadened as he proposed a universal council of the Church to put an end to all of the divisions in Christendom. Calvin envisioned a council that would include representatives from the whole church, including the Catholic bishops as well as representatives of the reformation churches. He was even open to the possibility that the pope would preside (but not rule!).”

    But what hath Geneva to do with Louisville? Everything.

    A. Donald MacLeod (Photo credit: Jeffrey McDonald)

    A. Donald MacLeod (Photo credit: Jeffrey McDonald)

    What if all of the mainliners and split P’s remained “truly one” as Jesus prayed in John 17:23? What if we all had been able to navigate between the Scylla and Charybdis of straightjacket rigidity of the Split P’s and the theological ambiguity of the mainline P’s these past eight decades? What if we could have avoided its plaguing eccentricities that have wounded Presbyterians ever since?

    I wonder, indeed, how much better shape the Reformed witness would be today in the church universal if we could place on the table a savory, robust and generous orthodoxy in place of current mishmash of mainline/split P soup.

    The third annual Presbyterian Scholars Conference on “The Future of American Presbyterianism” just might have been a baby step from what if … to what might be.

    The conference also established a Presbyterian history award in honor of A. Donald MacLeod. MacLeod has become known throughout the U.S. and Canada as an outstanding Christian biographer and historian of Presbyterianism and evangelicalism. Each year the winner of the MacLeod Award will receive a $1000 prize.

    Plans are in the works for a fourth conference next October at Wheaton College.

    chuck-wiggins1Chuck Wiggins is pastor of Trinity Presbyterian Church in Venice, Florida.

    Share this...
    Share on Facebook
    Facebook
    Pin on Pinterest
    Pinterest
    Tweet about this on Twitter
    Twitter
    Share on LinkedIn
    Linkedin

    Commentary Tags: More News - Homepage

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Related Posts

    • A Czech Visitor Looks at the PC(USA)

      The mission-partner-in-residence, as the job developed for me, is an itinerant, wandering preacher and presenter. In the period of one year I have traveled more than 28,000 miles by air and approximately an additional 2,500 miles by land. I preached, taught and spoke in 14 states in more than 20…

    • The Pathway to Partnership

      However, another significant document was approved at the 212th General Assembly, a policy statement of the Worldwide Ministries Division entitled "Presbyterians Do Mission in Partnership." Partnership is intrinsic to God's trinitarian nature and incarnational mission. We participate in God's mission in partnership with God, with partner churches and agencies around…

    • John 3:16 and the Prodigal: (The Gospel and the Gospel)

      For centuries the Latin tradition has called the famous parable of the compassionate father (i.e., the Prodigal Son) Evangelium in Evangelio (the Gospel within the Gospel). Thus should not "the Gospel" (Luke 15) agree with "the Gospel" (John 3:16)? That is, shouldn’t the summaries of John and Paul agree with…

    Current Issue

    • Feb 22
    • Feb 8
    • January 18
    • Dec 28
    • Subscribe
    • Give a Gift
    • Read Online
    • Most Commented
    • Most Popular
    • GA meeting site in Baltimore to be converted into field hospital A decision may be getting closer about whether to hold the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) – set...
    • Moving Forward Implementation Commission takes administrative action The Moving Forward Implementation Commission voted June 18 to take administrative action in five areas — with some of the...
    • Debate over relationship between San Francisco Theological Seminary and the PC(USA) may rise at General Assembly  When is a historically Presbyterian seminary no longer a "Presbyterian seminary”? That question is on the docket for the 224th General...
    • Churches go back to the future with drive-in services in the time of the coronavirus (RNS) — When it came time to pass the peace Sunday at Pathway Baptist Church, Senior Pastor Mike Donald didn’t...
    • Advent devotions — 2020 (Year B) Advent time: Devotions for the congregation Are you looking for theologically sound, inspiring and affordable Advent devotions for the congregation? The Presbyterian...
    • PC(USA) General Assembly affirms that Black lives matter; pledges to work against systemic racism The 2020 General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) voted overwhelmingly June 26 to approve a resolution declaring that Black...

    Keep the Faith

    Sign Up for Updates and Breaking News in your inbox

    Facebook

    Tweets by presoutlook
    Follow Us

    View Stories From

    • Presbyterian Hub
      • Editorials
      • Outlook Features
      • Digital Issues
      • Calendar Check
      • About People
        • Anniversaries
        • Ordinations
        • Retired
        • Deaths
        • Transitions
      • Archives
    • Faith + Culture
      • Book Reviews
      • Movie Reviews
      • He/She Said
    • Ministry + Theology
      • InSights Opinions
        • For Church Leaders
        • Faith Matters
        • Multichannel Church Report
        • #amen
        • Commentary
        • Benedictory
      • Liturgical Year
        • Advent
        • Lent

    The Latest:

    Holy promises — Christian ed at home

    February 24, 2021

    I’m wrestling with the COVID-19 vaccine…

    February 24, 2021

    Prophets of restoration (Apr. 4, 2021)

    February 23, 2021

  • Tweet With Us
  • Be A Facebook Fan
  • Our World in Photos
  • Pin With Us
  • CONTACT US:

    1 N. 5th St., Suite 500

    Richmond, VA 23219

    T: 800-446-6008F: 804-353-6369

    [email protected]

    Or ▶ Fill Out Our Contact Form

    © Copyright 2021 The Presbyterian Outlook. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Statement. Website Design by Poka Yoke Design

    • About us
    • Presbyterian Hub
    • Ministry Resources
    • Classifieds
    • Advertise with the Outlook
    • Submissions
    7ads6x98y